When it comes to finding synonyms for the word "puzzlingly," there are many options to choose from. Some of the most common synonyms include "confusingly," "bafflingly," and "mysteriously." Other possible options may include "perplexingly," "bewilderingly," or "obscurely." Depending on the context of the sentence or situation, one of these synonyms may be a more suitable choice than another. The key is to find a word that accurately conveys the sense of confusion or uncertainty that comes with something that is puzzling. With the right synonym, it is possible to add depth and nuance to any piece of writing or conversation.