Fatherly is a word used to describe a caring and protective paternal figure. However, when we need to express the same sentiment but with a different connotation, we might look to synonyms. Here are some alternatives to 'more fatherly.' Firstly, 'paternal' is a common option. It stresses a warm, supportive, and guidance-giving parental relationship. Secondly, 'avuncular' emphasizes the importance of a loving yet slightly more relaxed, joking dynamic, akin to the relationship with an uncle. Lastly, 'patriarchal' carries a more authoritarian suggestion. It connotes a powerful father figure who holds sway over the family unit and encourages traditional gender roles. Each synonym offers its own unique twist on the concept of a caring, paternal figure.